What is category management analysis?
Short answer
Category management analysis is the fact-finding stage for one category: what is bought, from whom, at what price and under which contracts, how the supply market works, and where value can be gained.
Key takeaways
- Category management analysis builds the fact base for one category before any strategy is chosen: spend, demand, contracts, suppliers, prices, the supply market and the risks.
- It looks inside the organisation first (what we buy and how) and then outside (what the market can offer), and ends with a short list of sized opportunities.
- The output is a category profile: a few pages of facts with their dates and sources that the category strategy is built on.
- Price differences between sites or business units for the same service can be the first and clearest opportunity, as in the worked example.
- Size each opportunity with a stated method, agree that method with finance, and say where the data is weak rather than wait for perfect data.
What is category management analysis?
Category management analysis is the work of collecting and studying the facts about one category of spend, such as cleaning services or laptops, before deciding how to buy it. It covers internal spend, demand and contracts, the suppliers used, the prices paid, the supply market and the risks, and ends with a list of opportunities sized in money.
Take a common case. A new category manager takes over cleaning services for an organisation with 25 offices. Before she can propose a tender, a new contract model or a change in cleaning frequency, she needs to know how much is spent, with how many suppliers, at what price per square metre, under which contracts, and how many companies could serve all the sites. Collecting and testing those facts is category management analysis.
This page covers the analysis for one category. What category management is, and how categories are segmented, is in what is category management. The techniques used, such as the Kraljic matrix, ABC analysis and STEEPLED analysis, are compared in category management tools. How the facts become a strategy is in how do you write a category management strategy.
What questions does the analysis answer?
The analysis answers two sets of questions: what the organisation buys and how, and what the market can offer. UK central government’s commercial standard describes category management as the approach that “aligns organisational spend and requirements with supply market capability and capacity”; the analysis provides the facts for both sides of that match.
- Spend. How much is spent in the category per year, with which suppliers, by which sites or business units, and how is it trending?
- Demand. What is bought, in what volumes, and why? Are some units buying more, or a higher specification, than they need?
- Contracts. Which share of the spend is under contract, when do the contracts end, and what notice periods apply?
- Prices and costs. What is paid per unit, how much does it vary, and what drives the supplier’s cost (labour, materials, energy, transport)?
- Suppliers. How do current suppliers perform, how dependent is the organisation on each, and how important is the organisation to them?
- Supply market. How many suppliers could serve the need, how competitive the market is, and what is changing in it?
- Risk. What could interrupt supply or raise prices, and how serious would it be?
The Victorian Government’s market analysis guide puts the outside questions simply: are there enough suppliers likely to respond, what is the likelihood of competitive pricing and performance, and what is the risk of failure in that market sector. Its stated goal is to identify the most relevant approach to the market, which is also the goal of the analysis as a whole.
How do you run a category analysis, step by step?
- Set the scope. List the sub-categories, the ledger accounts or classification codes that belong to the category, and the period, usually the last 12 to 24 months. The Victorian guidance defines a category as a grouping of goods or services with common supply and demand drivers and suppliers; use that test to decide what belongs in it.
- Build the spend baseline. Extract the spend, clean supplier names, remove items that are not supplier spend, and group it by sub-category, supplier and site. The method is detailed in spend analysis.
- Analyse demand and specifications. Compare volumes and specifications between sites. Ask the main users what they need and what does not work.
- Review contracts and suppliers. Build a register of the category’s contracts with their end dates, and collect each main supplier’s performance and risk records.
- Compare prices and costs. Calculate unit prices (per hour, per item, per square metre) by site and supplier. For larger categories, a should-cost model estimates what the work ought to cost from its inputs; the UK Sourcing Playbook requires one for complex outsourcing projects in central government.
- Analyse the supply market. Count possible suppliers, note their size and reach, and list the outside changes that affect prices, such as a minimum wage increase.
- Position and size the opportunities. Place sub-categories on the Kraljic matrix by profit impact and supply risk, list the opportunities, and estimate each one in money with a stated method.
- Write the category profile. Summarise the facts, their dates and their limits in a few pages, and hand it to the people who will write the category strategy.
What goes into a category profile?
The category profile is the written output of the analysis. Keep it short enough to be read by budget holders, with detailed data in appendices.
| Section | Question it answers | Typical data source |
|---|---|---|
| Scope | What belongs in the category, and what does not? | Classification codes, ledger accounts, category tree |
| Spend baseline | How much, with whom, by which units, trend over time? | Accounts payable and purchase order data, cleaned and classified |
| Demand | What is bought, how much, to which specification, and why? | Order lines, service records, interviews with users |
| Contracts | What share is under contract, and when does each contract end? | Contract register |
| Prices and costs | What is paid per unit, how much does it vary, what drives cost? | Invoices, price lists, should-cost estimates |
| Suppliers | How do current suppliers perform and how dependent are we? | Scorecards, incident logs, financial checks |
| Supply market | How many suppliers, how much competition, what is changing? | Market research, requests for information, trade bodies |
| Risks | What could interrupt supply or raise prices? | Risk register, supplier alerts, market news |
| Opportunities | Where is the value, how much, and with what confidence? | The analysis above, with the sizing method stated |
Date every figure and name its source; a profile without dates cannot be refreshed or checked.
What does a category analysis look like on real figures?
The worked example below follows the cleaning category from the opening case. All figures are fictional. The organisation spends €2.4 million a year on office cleaning across 25 offices with a total floor area of 100,000 square metres, an average of €24 per square metre per year.
| Finding | Figure | What it suggests |
|---|---|---|
| Annual spend | €2.4 million, 14 suppliers | Many suppliers for one service; room to consolidate |
| Supplier concentration | Top 3 suppliers hold 78% of spend | The other 11 suppliers serve small sites at local prices |
| Spend under contract | 62% | 38% is bought without a current contract |
| Price, group 1 sites | 60,000 m² at €21 per m² per year (€1.26 million) | The price level the market already accepts |
| Price, group 2 sites | 40,000 m² at €28.50 per m² per year (€1.14 million) | Same service, about a third more expensive |
| Demand | 10,000 m² of storage cleaned daily | Frequency higher than use requires |
| Supply market | Six companies can serve all 25 sites | Enough competition for a tender |
The price gap between the two groups of sites is the largest opportunity, and the market has enough suppliers to act on it.
Sizing follows from the table. Bringing group 2 down to €24 per square metre, still above group 1 to allow for older buildings, saves 40,000 × €4.50 = €180,000 a year, 7.5% of the category. Cleaning the storage areas twice a week instead of daily is a demand change; its value has to be estimated with the current suppliers’ rates before it is counted. Moving the 38% of spend without a contract under a new contract is a control gain as well as a price gain. The category strategy then decides which of these to pursue, and how.
How is category analysis done in the public sector?
Public buyers use the same analysis with two additions. First, the depth of market analysis is scaled to the value and risk of the purchase: the Victorian guidance calls the level of detail “scalable” and asks for a detailed analysis when an activity is critical to the business or high risk. Second, the analysis often measures how much spend is already under managed contracts. The US Office of Management and Budget’s memorandum M-19-13 sorts federal spend into tiers, from unaligned spend to Best In Class contracts, and asks agencies to reduce unaligned spend.
Market analysis in the public sector also has limits on contact with suppliers: a buyer may consult the market before a tender, but must not give any supplier an advantage. How public buyers handle this is covered in public procurement.
Where does category analysis usually go wrong?
- Spend only, no market. The team knows what it buys but not what the market could offer, so the strategy repeats last year’s tender.
- Waiting for perfect data. Weeks go into cleaning the last few percent of spend. State the gap and move on.
- Totals instead of unit prices. Two sites spending the same amount can pay very different prices per unit; only unit prices show it.
- No users asked. Demand opportunities, such as the storage cleaning in the example, are found by talking to the people who use the service.
- Opportunities without a method. A savings figure that finance cannot recompute is argued about later. Write down how each figure was calculated.
- A profile that is never refreshed. Markets and spend change. Update the profile before each strategy review, for example once a year.
Questions
What is the difference between category analysis and spend analysis?
Spend analysis looks at what the organisation has spent, across all categories. Category analysis uses the spend of one category as its starting point and adds demand, contracts, prices, suppliers, the supply market and risks, then sizes the opportunities. Spend analysis is one input to category analysis.
How long does a category analysis take?
It depends on the size of the category and the quality of the data. A simple category with clean data can be profiled in a few weeks; a large one with many sites, suppliers and poor data takes longer. Agree a date with the sponsor and record the data gaps rather than extend the work.
Who does the category analysis?
The category manager leads it, with help from a spend or data analyst for the baseline, finance for the cost figures and savings method, and the main users for demand. In larger organisations a procurement analytics team prepares the spend and price data for all categories.
Is category management analysis in retail the same thing?
No. In retail, category management analysis looks at the products a store sells: sales, margins, shelf space, promotions and shopper behaviour. In procurement, it looks at what the organisation buys for its own use. Both study a category as a whole, but the data and the goals differ.
New guides on the strategic sourcing line
One short email when a guide on this line is added or revised. Nothing else.
Coming soon: sign-up opens with the first email.